When designing a pool, one technical choice has a big effect on both the look and the cost: whether to build an overflow pool or a skimmer pool. The difference is in how the water level is managed and how the surface is kept clean, and it shows in the pool's appearance, its circulation, its cost and its maintenance. Both are proper, widely used systems, but they suit different ambitions and budgets. This guide compares overflow and skimmer pools in Dubai to help you choose.
What a skimmer pool is
A skimmer pool is the more common and conventional type. The water level sits a little below the top edge (coping) of the pool, and skimmers, openings set into the pool wall at the waterline, draw in surface water, along with floating debris, to be filtered and returned. It is a proven, efficient and cost-effective system used in the majority of pools. The water line is visible against the pool wall, which is the familiar look of most pools. For many homes, a skimmer pool is a straightforward, reliable and economical choice that does its job well.
What an overflow pool is
An overflow pool, also called a deck-level or infinity-edge-style pool (though distinct from a true vanishing-edge infinity pool), has the water level right at the top edge, so water continuously overflows the rim into a surrounding channel (a gutter or grate) and is then filtered and returned. The result is a seamless, mirror-like surface flush with the surrounding deck, with no visible waterline against a wall. It is a more sophisticated, premium look and an excellent surface-skimming system, but it is more complex and costly to build. Overflow systems are often chosen for high-end, architectural pools where the flush, continuous water surface is desired.
The look
Appearance is the most visible difference. A skimmer pool has the conventional look, with the water sitting below the coping and a visible waterline on the pool wall. An overflow pool has the water brimming to the very edge and spilling over all around, creating a striking, flush, mirror-like surface level with the deck, with no visible waterline. For a contemporary, architectural, high-end aesthetic, the overflow look is hard to beat, while the skimmer look is the familiar, perfectly attractive appearance of most pools. If the seamless, brimming water surface is important to your design, that points to an overflow pool.
Water circulation and cleanliness
Both systems keep the surface clean, but in different ways and to different degrees. A skimmer pool draws surface water and debris through skimmers at points around the pool, which works well. An overflow pool skims the entire surface continuously over its whole perimeter, which is highly effective at keeping the surface clean and the water well circulated, since the top layer, where debris, oils and warmth collect, is constantly carried off. This all-round surface skimming is one of the functional advantages of an overflow pool, in addition to its looks, giving excellent water surface cleanliness and circulation.
Cost
Cost is where the skimmer pool has the clear advantage. A skimmer pool is simpler and more economical to build, making it the cost-effective choice for most homes. An overflow pool is more complex and costly, requiring the perimeter overflow channel, a balance tank to hold the overflowing water, additional plumbing and a larger pump system, all of which add significantly to the build cost, and somewhat to the running cost. The overflow pool's premium look and performance come at a premium price. Whether that is justified depends on your budget and how much the flush surface matters to you, which is part of the decision.
Complexity to build
An overflow pool is a more demanding construction. The level of the overflow edge must be precise all the way around for the water to spill evenly, the perimeter channel and balance tank must be correctly built and sized, and the larger pump system must be properly specified. This complexity means an overflow pool should be built by a company experienced in them, as errors show in uneven overflow or performance problems. A skimmer pool is a more straightforward, well-established build. The additional complexity of an overflow pool is part of its cost and part of why it is considered a premium choice, and it reinforces the importance of a capable builder.
Maintenance
Both systems require regular maintenance, but there are differences. A skimmer pool's maintenance is straightforward and familiar, including keeping the skimmer baskets clear. An overflow pool, with its continuous surface skimming, keeps the surface very clean, but it has more components, the channel, balance tank and larger system, to maintain, and the water level and system must be kept correct for the overflow to work evenly. Neither is difficult to maintain with proper servicing, but the overflow pool's greater complexity means a little more to look after. A good pool service handles either, and this is worth factoring into ownership.
Which suits your home
The right choice depends on your priorities and budget. A skimmer pool suits most homes well: it is cost-effective, reliable, proven and perfectly attractive, and is the sensible default for many. An overflow pool suits those who want a premium, architectural, flush-surface aesthetic and excellent all-round surface circulation, and who have the budget for the additional cost and complexity. There is no universally better option; it is a matter of what you want from the pool and what you are prepared to spend. Being honest about how much the overflow look matters to you, versus the cost, guides the decision.
A skimmer pool is the cost-effective, reliable, conventional choice that suits most homes. An overflow pool delivers a premium, flush, mirror-like surface and excellent circulation at a higher cost and complexity. The right one depends on your look, budget and ambition.
The balance tank explained
One component worth understanding, because it explains much of the cost difference, is the balance tank that an overflow pool requires. In a skimmer pool, the pool itself holds all the water and the level simply rises and falls a little. In an overflow pool, the water that continuously spills over the edge has to go somewhere, so it flows into a separate balance tank, usually hidden underground nearby, which holds this water and feeds it back through the filtration and return system. The balance tank also accommodates the water displaced when swimmers get in, and the changes in level through the day. This hidden tank, along with the perimeter channel and larger pump system, is part of why an overflow pool is more complex and costly to build, and it must be correctly sized and built for the system to work smoothly. Understanding it helps explain why an overflow pool is a bigger undertaking than a skimmer pool.
Making the decision
To decide, weigh how much the seamless overflow look and the all-round surface skimming matter to you against the significant additional cost and complexity. If a conventional, attractive pool that does its job reliably and economically is what you want, a skimmer pool is an excellent choice. If you are designing a high-end, architectural pool and the flush, brimming water surface is central to that vision, and the budget allows, an overflow pool delivers it beautifully. A reputable pool company will explain both honestly for your project and help you decide, rather than pushing the more expensive option regardless. Our pool construction service builds both to a high standard.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an overflow and a skimmer pool? A skimmer pool keeps the water below the coping and skims the surface through openings in the wall. An overflow pool has the water at the very edge, spilling over into a perimeter channel, giving a flush, mirror-like surface with no visible waterline.
Which is cheaper? A skimmer pool, clearly. It is simpler and more economical to build, while an overflow pool requires a perimeter channel, balance tank, extra plumbing and a larger pump system, adding significantly to the cost.
Which looks better? It is a matter of taste. A skimmer pool has the familiar, attractive look of most pools; an overflow pool has a striking, flush, mirror-like surface level with the deck, favoured for contemporary, high-end, architectural designs.
Is an overflow pool better at staying clean? It skims the entire surface continuously over its whole perimeter, which is highly effective at keeping the surface clean and the water circulated, an advantage over the point-skimming of a skimmer pool, though both keep a pool clean with proper servicing.
Which should I choose? A skimmer pool suits most homes, being cost-effective, reliable and attractive. An overflow pool suits a premium, architectural design where the flush surface is central and the budget allows the extra cost and complexity. It depends on your look, budget and ambition.
Choose the right pool system
Whether a skimmer or overflow pool suits you depends on your look and budget. Book a free site visit and we will explain both for your project and give you a design and an itemised quote. See our pool construction service for how we work.